Hollywood still calls it Christmas, but the birth of Christ rarely makes it into the script. (illustration)

As Netflix rolls out its 2026 Christmas lineup, the classic holiday films Americans watch every December show how far the genre has moved. Of the best-known classics, only A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965) tells the story of Christ’s birth. In the school auditorium, Linus recites Luke 2:8–14 from the King James Bible, announcing, “For unto you is born this day in the city of David a Saviour, which is Christ the Lord.”

Peanuts creator Charles Schulz kept the Scripture reading in over the objections of the producer and the animator, who believed having Linus recite the Bible crossed a line.

The other classics contain few Christian references or none. Adaptations of A Christmas Carol center on the three ghosts who visit Ebenezer Scrooge, with Tiny Tim making a passing reference to Christ. Home Alone includes a brief church scene with a choir singing “O Holy Night.” It’s a Wonderful Life, Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, Frosty the Snowman and Elf never tell the story of the Nativity. However, these films deal with themes of family, generosity or redemption, and none of them mocks the faith behind the holiday.

A Times analysis of 424 Hallmark and Lifetime holiday movies found that 73 percent had “Christmas” in the title. In 2023, just 53 percent of Hallmark’s 40 holiday titles did. Hallmark programming executive Lisa Hamilton Daly told The New York Times, “you run out of adjectives and adverbs to use with Christmas at some point.” Netflix’s Holidate (2020) uses multiple holidays as the backdrop for its romance, including New Year’s, Valentine’s Day, Easter, St. Patrick’s Day, Independence Day and Halloween.

Hollywood has gone a step further, moving from leaving Christ out of Christmas to mocking him. The clearest example is The First Temptation of Christ, a Christmas special Netflix released on Dec. 3, 2019. The Brazilian comedy troupe Porta dos Fundos (Back Door) produced the special. Netflix’s own description read, “Jesus, who’s hitting the big 3-0, brings a surprise guest to meet the family.” In the special, Jesus brings home a homosexual lover to meet Mary and Joseph.

More than 1.76 million people signed a petition demanding that Netflix remove the special. Bishop Joseph Strickland of Tyler, Texas, canceled his subscription and wrote that “blasphemers don’t deserve a penny of support!” On Christmas Eve 2019, attackers threw Molotov cocktails at the troupe’s Rio de Janeiro headquarters. The special remained on Netflix until September 2021.

Netflix returned to the Nativity story in its 2024 animated children’s film That Christmas, written by Richard Curtis, the director of Love Actually. In one scene, children stage a school Nativity play that a teenage character rewrites as a “strictly vegetarian, multi-cultural fun fest with lots of pop songs” and material about climate change.

The shepherds herd vegetables, the wise men become wise women, and the girl playing Mary holds up a watermelon with a carved face as baby Jesus while singing Madonna’s 1986 song “Papa Don’t Preach,” about a pregnant teenager deciding to keep her baby.

That same month, on Dec. 6, 2024, Netflix released Mary. D.J. Caruso, a Catholic, directed the film, with Anthony Hopkins as Herod and televangelist Joel Osteen among its executive producers.

When Mary arrives in Bethlehem in labor, the devil appears and offers to ease her pain. The film also adds violence found nowhere in Scripture. Herod places a crown of thorns on a priest and gouges out his eyes. Caruso told Catholic News Agency that every decision was made “to pay great reverence to this amazing woman and her life.”

The use of Christian imagery extended beyond Christmas releases. In April 2026, the New York film studio A24 released Mother Mary, giving the Virgin Mary’s title to the pop star at the center of the film. Anne Hathaway plays the title character, whose songs include “Holy Spirit.” Citing a séance and an exorcism ritual, Movieguide called the film’s mixture of Christian and occult symbolism “abhorrent.”

Other Netflix holiday originals put sexual content at the center of the story. Netflix’s Tudum site describes The Merry Gentlemen (2024), built around an all-male Christmas show, as “the story of a steamy musical revue that just might save Christmas.” In Hot Frosty (2024), a snowman comes to life as a nude man, according to Movieguide’s content review.

LGBTQ storylines have become a fixture of the holiday lineup. Hallmark included same-sex couples in its Christmas movies for six straight years, beginning with The Christmas House in 2020. Netflix promoted Single All the Way (2021) as its first gay Christmas movie, and the film remains in its holiday library.

In 2025, Hallmark aired A Keller Christmas Vacation, in which a gay man proposes to his boyfriend on a family river cruise, and The Christmas Baby, about a lesbian couple who find a baby on their doorstep. Amazon’s Prime Video released Oh. What. Fun., in which Chloë Grace Moretz plays the daughter of Michelle Pfeiffer’s character. The daughter has a girlfriend. On Nov. 29, Lifetime premieres A Firefighter’s Christmas Calendar, a lesbian holiday romance.

Sixty-one years after Linus recited Luke 2 on network television, Netflix’s two most recent films about the birth of Jesus have rewritten the story, one as a school-play parody and the other with scenes found nowhere in Scripture. Over the same period, Christian studios such as Angel Studios have posted some of the strongest results in the film industry.

The post From Leaving Christ Out of Christmas to Mocking Him: Netflix’s Gay Jesus Special, a Nativity Parody and Hollywood’s Newest Holiday Films appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *