‘How did you go bankrupt?’ Bill asked.
‘Two ways,’ Mike said. ‘Gradually and then suddenly.’
It’s one of my favourite exchanges from Hemingway’s first novel, The Sun Also Rises, that has since become shorthand in financial circles for how crashes happen.
For years, Australians have been strapped to something akin to a medieval torture rack, stretched between inflation and interest rate rises one agonising notch at a time.
This week, it feels as though things finally broke.
On Thursday, the ABS revealed unemployment had jumped to 4.9 per cent in October, a five-year high.
The unexpected jump in unemployment triggered the ‘Sahm Rule’, named after former US Federal Reserve economist Claudia Sahm, who I’ve had the pleasure of meeting during my studies abroad.
The rule holds that when the three-month average unemployment rate rises half a percentage point above its low over the previous 12 months, the economy has likely entered a recession.
The folly of the Reserve Bank’s dual mandate, to keep inflation low while maintaining full employment, has been exposed for the contradiction it is.
‘The most concerning aspect of the October jobs report is not just the trend itself, but that the data reflects economic conditions from months ago,’ says David Scutt, a senior market analyst at StoneX Financial.
GDP per capita has been in recession for some time. We’ve all felt it.
Until now, immigration-fuelled population growth has helped prop up headline GDP, allowing Australia to avoid a conventional recession.
(GDP can grow simply because there are more people in the country, even as the average Australian becomes worse off.)
Even that is no longer enough to keep our Ponzi economy going.
In the past two months, roughly 80,000 jobs have disappeared, and fewer people are employed today than in March, even though there are 205,000 more working-age people in the country.
In the last fortnight, David Jones, after 188 years in business, and General Pants Co collapsed into administration, with about 6,500 jobs at risk between them.
Bunnings is sending 350 tech jobs offshore in the name of AI, following similar moves at Qantas and NAB, while those still in a job are going backwards.
Wages rose 3.5 per cent over the year to September, while prices rose 4.3 per cent.
What little job growth remains is concentrated in taxpayer-funded sectors such as healthcare and social assistance, and yes, you guessed it, the NDIS.
In accommodation and food services, where so many young Australians get their first job, real wages are lower than in 1997.
Since Covid, the average worker who stayed in the same job, without extra hours or new skills, has had pay rises of about 23 per cent. Meanwhile, prices have risen 28 per cent, on a conservative estimate.
The data centre boom, which has sucked investment away from other parts of the economy in a manner reminiscent of Dutch disease, is now looking increasingly vulnerable as AI stocks tumble in the worst November since 1987.
After suffering all that AI-induced inflation, what do we have to show for it? A menagerie of Silicon Valley billionaires, while the rest of us are left in purgatory.
The majority of the blame for the state of the Australian economy lies at the feet of the government, which kept its foot firmly on the spending accelerator while the Reserve Bank tried in vain to tap the brakes.
By pumping demand into an economy already struggling with inflation, government spending has made the Reserve Bank’s job harder, forcing interest rates to remain higher for longer, and pushing the economy to breaking point.
The ASX has fallen to levels last seen 18 months ago, while the Australian dollar, a handy barometer for the health of the economy, is at its lowest since January.
There is simply nothing to invest in anymore.
And while the economy burned back home, the Prime Minister was in Antalya for COP31, telling world leaders that climate change was his priority while sipping $32,000 worth of taxpayer-funded coffee.
In May, I wrote that a recession was coming. Now, some of Australia’s leading economists are conceding a recession is a ‘coin flip’, but if you ask me, that’s now the best-case scenario.
With house prices falling at their fastest rate in history, AI disruption threatening more jobs, consumer spending weakening and global share markets tanking, a deeper depression is no longer out of the question.
To paraphrase another favourite line, from Those Who Remain:
‘Good times have allowed weak men to run the country. Weak men have created hard times. The coming hard times will have to create strong men.’
The post Gradually, then suddenly: the week Australia’s economy broke appeared first on The Spectator Australia.


