A reader recently accused me of being nostalgic. It was intended as a rebuke – the usual suggestion that anyone dissatisfied with the present must be pining for a sepia-tinted past. The more I thought about it, the more I realised he was right. I am nostalgic. Just not for the past.

I remember watching Malcolm Turnbull’s first press conference after he took the Prime Ministership from Tony Abbott. He looked into the cameras and declared: ‘There has never been a more exciting time to be an Australian.’

My first thought was: you prick.

The Liberals had spent years ridiculing Labor for the Rudd-Gillard-Rudd revolving door, then took power and did exactly the same thing. Apparently, changing Prime Ministers midstream was a constitutional outrage right up until the Liberals found someone they preferred.

Still, Abbott had made some poor calls. Knights and dames were difficult to explain even to people who liked him. The government had lost its rhythm, the polls were ugly, and perhaps I’d misread the tea leaves. Turnbull was intelligent, articulate and successful. The whole production felt wrong, but perhaps the result would be right. Perhaps the public would forgive the method if he delivered something better.

And, damn him, it was a very good line. Worse, it was exactly what I wanted to hear.

Turnbull had crystallised in a sentence the future Australians of my generation had been promised. I grew up through the Hawke and Keating years and came of age under Howard and Costello. Different parties, different philosophies, but a broadly shared proposition: endure the difficult reforms, repair the books, modernise the economy, and tomorrow will be better than today.

There had been a recession. Unemployment hurt families. Governments made mistakes. But the direction of travel seemed clear. Australia was opening up, growing richer and becoming more confident. We were safe, prosperous and blessed with space, resources, and abundant energy. If we managed those gifts sensibly, our children would inherit something even better.

We weren’t promised a nation of billionaires. We were promised a country in which an ordinary life could still be a very good one.

A working couple could buy a home without entering a 30-year hostage negotiation. Energy would be cheap and reliable because Australia possessed almost indecent quantities of it. Infrastructure would broadly keep pace with population. Institutions would be competent, streets would be safe and people who worked hard could expect to move forward. Australia didn’t need to become America. Our promise was simpler: security, opportunity, and enough room to breathe.

A generation later, that future has gone missing.

Housing has become a speculative blood sport. Governments pour people into cities without pouring the concrete required to accommodate them. Energy-rich Australia has engineered expensive and increasingly uncertain power, then congratulated itself on its sophistication. The economy can grow on paper while Australians go backwards in real life. Businesses spend more time satisfying regulators, consultants, and compliance departments than creating anything. Public services cost more, deliver less, and still find room in the budget for another awareness campaign.

When none of that works, the political class starts a culture war to keep everybody occupied. Nothing distracts from a collapsing standard of living quite like ordering citizens to argue over terminology.

This is where the accusation of nostalgia usually arrives. Anyone who thinks Australia has lost something is assumed to want the 1950s restored, complete with milk bars, six o’clock closing and a government department to inspect the length of men’s hair.

I don’t want to return to the Australia of my childhood. I want to live in the Australia my childhood was told it was building.

I don’t miss bank queues, dial-up internet, or cigarette smoke hanging over every restaurant meal. I miss the assumption that progress meant life becoming easier, richer and freer. Today, ‘progress’ often means paying more for something that works less reliably while a minister explains why the inconvenience is good for us.

Lee Kuan Yew looked south from Singapore and warned that a complacent Australia could squander its inheritance. We treated it as the impertinence of a small country lecturing a large and fortunate one. The joke has aged badly. Australians now arrive in Singapore and marvel at the infrastructure, cleanliness and administrative competence. We needn’t imitate its political system to notice that it built things while we commissioned reviews.

Turnbull isn’t responsible for all of this. His press conference matters because it marks the moment the future began to feel less like a national project and more like a marketing campaign. Our leaders became fluent in the vocabulary of tomorrow – innovation, agility, transition – while presiding over the steady deterioration of today.

That is the real betrayal. Australia didn’t fail to remain unchanged. It changed without advancing. We accepted higher costs, smaller ambitions, longer commutes, weaker services, and less control over our lives, and were told every downgrade was evidence of enlightenment.

So yes, I am nostalgic. I’m nostalgic for the compact that said we would do difficult things now to build a better country later. Australians did the difficult things. Later arrived. The better country didn’t.

I’m not nostalgic for the past. I’m nostalgic for the future we were promised.

The future used to be something Australian governments built. Now it just seems to be something they announce.

The post I’m nostalgic for the future we were promised appeared first on The Spectator Australia.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *