You have probably heard of Ethelred the Unready, who was badly advised. Or King Canute, who showed that he could not turn the tide. Or King Harold, who caught an arrow in the eye.

Until recently, however, you would be forgiven for not having heard of Athelstan, whose more plausible claim to fame is that he united England in 927. He is becoming mainstream, though, after a long-running campaign involving historian Tom Holland and a handful of MPs, including medieval history buff Alex Burghart, Ed Davey and Neil O’Brien. There are now even calls for the Culture Secretary to commemorate the 1,100th anniversary of our country in 2027.

The Athelstan project feels more like the sort of performative, romantic revivalism that the Scots, Germans and Italians went in for in the nineteenth century

Perhaps in the past we have paid too much attention to William the Conqueror, Magna Carta, King Harold and Canute. But these are our stories, and they have stood the test of time. The Athelstan project, by contrast, feels more like the sort of performative, romantic revivalism that the Scots, Germans and Italians went in for in the nineteenth century.

Athelstan is at odds, too, with the figures our nation normally holds in affection: the one-eyed, one-armed admiral, the hapless Scott and the stoic Oates. More recently, we’ve had Eddie the Eagle, Bridget Jones, Clive Sinclair, Frank Bruno, Arthur Dent – the list goes on. Even Alfred, who was a great king, burned his cakes while hiding in the marshes.

A national holiday to celebrate Athelstan, therefore, feels about as English as a presidential ballroom. Above all, it flies in the face of English understatement. This trait of ours is not an idiosyncrasy. It is integral to how we treat one another, more fundamental to our national character than any dates, kings or ancestry. That is why, if we really want to strengthen our sense of national identity, we must begin by recognising the importance of our language. For the truest test of what it is to be English – or British for that matter – is how we speak to one another, especially those we don’t know. How we mix understatement with humour and reserve, unless a line is crossed when liberties are taken.

England is still a country where, for the most part, the ‘first link’ to wider society and love of country is a band of people – what Edmund Burke called ‘the little platoon’.

Orwell recognised something similar, writing in 1941 that England is a ‘family,’ even if we have ‘the wrong members in control.’ The platoons we inhabit comprise relatives, neighbours, colleagues and teammates. But we are also able to band together with strangers, when required, because we speak the same lingo. In practice, we don’t put each other down because we don’t like to be put upon ourselves.

This draws on our history of toleration and consent. Our barons stood up to the king. The regions stood up to the palace. Taxpayers stood up to the sovereign. Merchants stood up to the aristocrats. Nonconformists stood up to the established church. Workers combined and stood up to their masters. Women stood up to men. And in the end, of course, our colonies stood up to us. It is uniquely our history, and it is embedded in our language and laws.

The way we speak in public does sometimes lay us open to the charge of being unemotional, indirect and aloof. But it has protected us from demagogues and extremists, while leaving us free to be more expressive and creative in private. That is the English bargain.

Inevitably, there is a political context for commemorating our country’s 1,100th anniversary. Burke’s platoons link us together as a country and connect us to our past and future, but only so long as we actually talk to one another. Not when whole neighbourhoods turn in on themselves and when change is too rapid and uncontrolled. Nor when rabble-rousers on both the left and right carve us up into opposing group identities. Then the links start to break.

Would a revivalist national holiday help counter this and shore up our national identity? For those who are already patriots, it might highlight the continuity of our history over 11 centuries. But for everyone else, it’s unlikely to change their attitude. And there is a real risk that the occasion would be manipulated by those who like to emphasise the ethnic origins of our nation. Take Elon Musk, who citing Tolkien, said the ‘gentlefolk of the English shires’ depend for their protection on the ‘hard men of Gondor.’

Musk would likely say that English culture has historically been predominantly carried by white people, because that is factually true. But the language used by Musk and his English acolytes could not be more un-English. It is all about provoking and inflaming with soundbites that cut through online and get headlines.

All too often, the politicians with the smoothest hands revel in this kind of fighting talk. They speak of ‘military-age men,’ ‘lethal force’ and ‘invasions’ as if there were an armada of marauding Vikings landing on our beaches. They invoke the name of Winston Churchill for their own purposes and wrap themselves (in a very American fashion) in the nation’s banner.

We must, therefore, be careful not to kindle these flames. Just as we need our leaders to be judicious in the words they choose. They should trust the public, who know that, when push comes to shove, we can unite to form a band of brothers – irrespective of ethnicity. But also that, when given the chance, we demobilise into our platoons, our shopkeeping ways, our hobbies and gardens. Our mastery of understated banter does not make English culture clawless. We simply take advantage of our good fortune in being an island nation.

So, if you are a medieval enthusiast and want to dress up in chainmail, festoon your streets with bunting and parade the flag of Saint George (a martyr from modern-day Turkey), then knock yourself out. And if – like the Lib Dem MP Josh Babarinde – you want to rebuke Suella Braverman by arguing that the census should allow black and Asian Brits to identify as ‘Black English’ and ‘Asian English’, then be my guest.

But if we really care about the unity of our nation, surely our time is better spent upholding the proper use of the English language. That means fluency for everyone and more free speech, public debate, and the study of English literature in schools. For herein lies the root cause of the failures that have fuelled the rise of ethnonationalists, notably the inability to stop mass illegal immigration and the reluctance to investigate the rape gangs properly. Political correctness – culminating in wokeness – has had an insidious effect on public discourse. It is more than just a battle within a broader culture war, because it targets the very language on which our culture depends. That is why it has been such a stealthy and successful adversary.

As an anglophone country, we were vulnerable to this US import. Its newspeak has warped the meanings of our words and the way we converse. It has changed our sense of humour and dulled our common sense. We have been cowed into silence because we are fearful of being called racist or phobic in half a dozen different ways. Collectively, we let activists and intellectuals cross the line without paying attention. And too many people ended up apologising for our history.

The answer, then, is not to adopt more historical heroes. Rather, we need to stop censoring ourselves and to defend and honour the ones we already have. We should also celebrate our current crop of royalty more loudly. I’d start with Raye, Rowling, Banksy, Dyson and Hassabis, but – this being England – everyone will have their own point of view.

We need more than just vibes, though. We need people in control of our national family who can both tell a positive story about our nation’s future and put those words into action by changing laws and raising standards (and fixing the navy). This is what we should be losing sleep over – not whether the fourth plinth in Trafalgar Square should be occupied by an Anglo-Saxon king.

The post The problem with celebrating Athelstan appeared first on The Spectator Australia.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *