Venezuelan illegal alien Carlos Suarez-Contreras, 26, kills Deborah Murphy, 82, in SUV
An illegal alien in Florida will not face criminal charges after backing over and killing an 82-year-old woman in a parking lot in May.
Security camera footage from the parking lot at a Publix grocery store in Panama City Beach shows the seconds before Venezuelan illegal alien Carlos Suarez-Contreras, 26, ran Deborah Murphy, a Florida grandmother, over.
Murphy was initially pushed to the ground, but the illegal alien did not stop until she was crushed by both sets of tires, Murphy’s daughter, Amy Edge, told Fox News.
He continued backing up, “running over Ms. Murphy,” according to the arrest affidavit.
Via Fox:
But now, his criminal case has been dismissed due to a strange loophole in Florida law, State Attorney Larry Basford said.
“I think everyone would agree that what he did was careless and it was negligent,” said Basford, adding, “not every tragedy amounts to a crime.”
The illegal alien was initially charged with driving with a canceled license and causing a death.
However, his Georgia license had been canceled the day before he killed Murphy, and prosecutors needed to “prove that the individual knew his license was suspended,” according to Basford.
Additionally, Florida law does not invalidate licenses issued to illegals in the state of Georgia, where non-citizens and illegal aliens are required to obtain licenses to establish residency. Illegal aliens can be considered a “resident” of Georgia if they are “present in the state for 30 or more days,” according to the Georgia Department of Driver Services
Prosecutors also failed to charge him with vehicular homicide and manslaughter because they couldn’t prove negligence or that he was driving “recklessly.” They don’t think he was driving fast enough!
“The prosecution’s memorandum relies on a reconstruction estimating the vehicle’s speed at four to five miles per hour. Yet the original crash report lists an estimated speed of 15 miles per hour. Our family believes this discrepancy warrants a clear explanation,” the family said.
“We know the man killed her,” daughter Amy Edge said. “He never got out of the car. He never ran to her aid. He never stopped. He wasn’t reversing from a spot. He drove backwards.”
The family further revealed that Suarez-Contreras was not given a drug or alcohol test after his arrest, and his cellphone records were not obtained to see if he was using his phone while driving.
“We don’t want him to be able to do this to anyone else in the United States. Our drive now is to ensure that he is deported,” Drive said.
Suarez-Contreras has been transferred into ICE custody, but the family is still urging State Attorney Larry Basford to “immediately reconsider” his decision to drop the case and to “reopen and complete the investigation.”
The family has launched a petition to pressure Florida prosecutors.
According to the petition:
Why This Decision Deserves Reconsideration
1. The circumstances of her death warrant closer scrutiny.
Deborah was walking in a marked pedestrian crosswalk. According to the crash report, Mr. Suarez Contreras’s vision was unobstructed, and Deborah did nothing improper.
The surveillance footage our family has seen shows Deborah in the crosswalk, in plain view, while the SUV reversed toward her. It then shows the vehicle striking her and continuing to reverse until both sets of wheels had passed over her.
Florida law prohibits backing a vehicle unless the maneuver can be completed safely.
Yet prosecutors concluded that the driver’s conduct was not reckless enough to support a vehicular homicide charge. We believe that conclusion should be reconsidered in light of all the circumstances.
2. Significant questions remain about the investigation.
Based on the investigative records and information provided to our family:
Mr. Suarez Contreras was not tested for alcohol or drugs.
His cellphone records were not obtained, even though the crash report coded him as “inattentive.”.
Only one independent witness was interviewed.
An off-duty first responder who gave Deborah emergency aid was never interviewed or contacted, even after our family identified him to prosecutors.
A Publix employee who photographed the scene and the driver’s vehicle was not interviewed, and her photographs were not obtained, as far as our family has been told.
The surveillance footage provided to our family ends while emergency aid is still being given to Deborah. That raises questions about whether additional footage was recorded, preserved, or obtained. No body-camera footage has been provided, and it remains unclear whether any exists.
How can prosecutors confidently conclude that the evidence is insufficient when potentially relevant evidence was never collected?
3. The official records contain significant discrepancies and unanswered questions.
The prosecution’s memorandum relies on a reconstruction estimating the vehicle’s speed at four to five miles per hour. Yet the original crash report lists an estimated speed of 15 miles per hour. Our family believes this discrepancy warrants a clear explanation.
The arrest affidavit’s description of the sequence of events also differs from what our family saw in the surveillance footage.
Questions also remain concerning the driver’s license records and about the driver’s actions immediately after the collision.
These discrepancies should be investigated and reconciled before the case is treated as closed.
4. Time may be running out.
After the decision not to prosecute, the driver was released from state custody and transferred to federal immigration custody.
If he is removed from the United States before charges are filed, it may become impossible to hold him accountable in Florida.
That is why prompt reconsideration is so important.
The post Outrageous: After Botched Investigation, Florida Prosecutors Drop Charges Against Illegal Alien Who Backed Over Grandmother in SUV – Family Launches Petition to Reopen Case (VIDEO) appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.


