I am at the stage in life where I simply cannot agree with the slogan: ‘The electorate always gets it right.’

I remember when the electorate thought Labor Prime Minister Gough Whitlam was great – he wasn’t. They woke up eventually, but only after he had made such a mess of things that voters felt the pain of their mistake.

Then there were punters who thought Liberal Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull had much more substance than his predecessor, Tony Abbott. I came home to my wife and said, ‘There’s the beginning of the end of the Libs.’ After all the criticism Turnbull laid out on the international stage against his own party, the Liberals allow him to remain a member. Their choice, of course.

In my view, the party has become weak. The last election confirmed my suspicions.

About two-thirds of the population in Australia leaned left on that occasion, and our con of a preferential voting system gave an openly socialist ‘comrade’ the reins of government – and isn’t he enjoying it! As are his buddies in Cabinet – look at the self-congratulating and perpetually smiling Chris Bowen, or the ‘attack dog’ of a Finance Minister, Ms Gallagher, or the stony-faced and almost incomprehensible Tony Burke and his sergeant at arms, the Foreign Minister.

History confirms how wrong the electorate can get things when voting. Sometimes the mistake is extreme. I was reminded of this while reading Mary Fulbrook’s Bystander Society. She reviewed what people wrote in the 1930s in Germany about their changing times. This included how they tried to explain their conformity and complicity, even in the face what appeared to be a clear moral choice – reject the evil killing of innocents.

She explains the process of the muddled middle this way:

‘Put very simply, for the muddled middle, this process ran roughly as follows: early evidence of Nazi brutality and widespread social pressures led initially to constrained consent and public conformity; over time, repeated rehearsals of behaviours and attitudes could become second nature; and eventually, as the apparatus of repression grew and millions were mobilised in service of a genocidal war of aggression, compliance would lead into more active complicity with the criminal acts of the Nazi regime.’

Here is my question.

With what issues are we in Australia currently behaving like the muddled middle?

That is, in what way has the Australian muddled middle been showing constrained consent and public conformity? Where has this way of thinking led to rehearsed behaviours that have become almost second nature to us? And where is this making us less humane because we have become less as humans?

I can think of the following areas in Australian political life.

The first is the climate alarmist movement. The level of public conformity in the face of uncertain hyped science is stunning. Think of all the failed predictions, dating from the time of US Vice President Al Gore and little Greta Thunberg. Or of the ‘rain that would never be enough’ gaffe regarding dams, the ‘reef is dead’ folk, and ‘the outlier events are increasing’ hippies.

The level of constrained consent in stopping coal-fired affordable energy has also enabled public consent for environmental damage when establishing wind and solar outside factories. We even consented to sell coal and uranium but not to use it here. It is, in effect, the consent to make ourselves more dependent on China. Two-thirds of votes two years ago had made this way of thinking and speaking a habit of life via the Labor and Green/Teal informal coalition.

Allied to this has been the constrained consent of Welcome to Country and smoking ceremonies. These are, in my view, based in paganism. In other words, a religious belief. Could you imagine if people were forced to partake in a Christian communion or Jewish spiritual ritual with such frequency? No doubt there would be objections. More than that, conformity is enforced through threats of being called racist if one does not partake. Australia has become a place where a Dreamtime story about a mythical bee can interfere with a mining investment. So much for Enlightenment or Natural Law thinking…

Then we have the trans and gender debate which finds its origins in post-modernism and Critical Theory. Personal identity has been mechanised (via Marx), sexualised (via Freud), and politicised (via the Frankfurt school). We have been forced to conform to this political framework which includes accepting, legally, that people choose their sex. Sex can be changed with a piece of paper allowing previous sex-based boundaries, such as in competitive sport and private segregated spaces, to be entered.

In a similar vein, the same system has struggled to handle hate preachers who rail against Australians, and particularly Jews. The teachings and presence is often glossed over, with the muddled middle reaching some form of unspoken conformity, perhaps herded there by hostile protest rallies. It is my view that these overstep the line, interfering with other people’s right to freedom of movement, freedom of business, and freedom of religious expression. Even the freedom to simply be at peace.

And then, as Dr Joanna Howe has described, there is the most important enforced conformity amongst our current suite of enforced conformities – the abortion debate, particularly the later-term debacle. I remember chatting with a senior State Labor Member of Parliament when we were both working on developing ways of supporting single pregnant teenagers. I asked him why people on neither side of politics would speak out about this parallel issue, which was offering pathways different to abortion, and his answer, though a bit crude, was clear: ‘The feminists have them all by the short and curlies.’ I am sure the irony of the metaphor was intended.

At the end of her book, Fulbrook noted that people in high places could have stopped Hitler, but most fell into line because they could benefit from his program. Who were these leaders? They included government ministers, civil servants, those in the military, lawyers, medical professionals, industry, churches, and universities. This is obviously the most extreme example, but it helps to illustrate the social mechanism.

There are many sections of our society, with real power, who could stop and say ‘enough’.

Too few do.

Most accept constrained speech and conformed conduct because they make comfortable livings from the industry involved.

What are we to do?

Fulbrook offers some almost muted advice. Basically, she asks that we pay more attention to the social and political dynamics that ‘foster widespread passivity in face of violence’ and how these kinds of environments breed ‘the varying routes into greater complicity and collaboration’.

To me, this falls flat. As our current circumstances in Australia demonstrate, if there is no heart for the principles of the universal dignity of all people to the point of being other-person-centred (which is the basis of establishing a common good), then the political processes towards having advantage over others simply takes over.

Why think about others if my purpose is to be as comfortable as I can (with my family as well, perhaps)? Why would I take risk? Why would I sacrifice anything of mine for the other? These questions became squashed by the sheer force of will.

So, what did the muddled middle do in the past, and what is our muddled middle doing now? Try and stay comfortable, making sure that they can survive each day.

What might snap us out of their stupor? Not a principled response to a loss of freedom of conscience or speech it seems – but, perhaps, it is a big enough a loss of physical certainty (money and what it can buy).

Are we close to that? Possibly. But snapping out of the economic doldrums will not stop the socialist enforced conformity to the destructive social agenda of the cultural neo-Marxists.

The post The muddled middle of Australian politics appeared first on The Spectator Australia.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *