In The Big Lebowski, one of my favourite all-time films, the two main characters have a memorable exchange in the context of things going seriously off the rails:
The Dude: ‘Nothing is f#$ed, here, man.’
The Big Lebowski: ‘Nothing is f^&ed?! The god damn plane has crashed into the mountain!’
There was a touch of The Big Lebowski in Housing Minister Clare O’Neil’s recent morning TV exchange with Liberal Senator Bridget McKenzie. As every day sees further diabolical data drop on home prices, rising interest rates, new builds, mortgage defaults, and declining home affordability, Clare O’Neil continues to do her best to turn lemons into lemonade, saying with a straight face last week, that the data reveals good news in that new home buyers as a percentage of total home purchases has increased. The host, Natalie Barr, and Senator McKenzie were having none of this highly selective cherry-picking, telling the Housing Minister, in terms, that the god damn plane has indeed crashed into the mountain.
In a similar vein, in his increasingly defensive public appearances, the Treasurer has continually sought the refuge of the war in Iran to blame for ever-spiralling interest rates. But no one is buying this. It’s become the equivalent of the ‘cat ate my homework’ excuse. Michelle Bullock is understated, but she knows how to land a point. In the media conference following the last rate rise, the latest of 16 prior rate rises, the RBA chief made it clear that domestic consumption and rampant government spending were the principal drivers of inflation, not the ‘war in Iran’ or ‘geopolitical issues in the Strait of Hormuz’.
The plain and indisputable reality is that this government has pulled many wrong economic reins since its return to government with a thumping majority. If the plane has not yet crashed into the mountain, then collision is imminent. Few serious political or economic commentators now seem willing to give the government a leave pass on its economic management, nor do these commentators say that they see a light at the end of the tunnel. Even some of the usually measured big four bank CEOs were prepared to diplomatically hint at major policy failure at last week’s Economic Standing Committee hearings. The government can be excused for seeking to put the most positive complexion on the economic data that it can, but the spin is beginning to strain credulity.
To stretch the metaphor, the government is running out of runway, or altitude to pull out of its nosedive. The prevailing headwinds are showing no sign of abating and by Easter we could well be in the grip of a recession. Consumer confidence has been shredded. For most Australians, the family home represents all or mostly all their household wealth. Even after decades of compulsory superannuation the family home remains the cornerstone family asset.
Although homes are only actually priced when they are sold, and their value will always fluctuate, when households are told their $1.5m home is now worth $1.3m they feel instantly poorer and lose confidence. This might be a reasonable price to pay if younger new home buyers were entering the market and affordability was improving, but the data shows that this is not happening. We find ourselves in a lose/lose situation. The short-term impacts of radical reform ‘to rebalance the tax system’ were seen by the Treasurer as warranted, but the forecast of only modest impacts on home prices (a reduction in growth by about 2 per cent) were wildly optimistic, and the cross current of rising interest rates and lower investment in housing supply was not considered in assessing home affordability for new buyers, nor were impacts on renters. This is hard to excuse as a simple miscalculation.
The singular focus on so-called generational equity in home ownership was always fundamentally flawed and drove several poor concurrent policy decisions, most notably negative gearing and capital gain tax reform. The government was widely and loudly warned that the budget would tank the housing market, reduce residential investment, increase rents, destroy consumer confidence, and produce no improvement in home loan affordability without more housing supply and lower interest rates. Similarly, the chilling effect on business large and small from increased tax burdens and lower incentives has resulted in widespread insolvencies, lower investment and a lack of trust in the government bordering on sovereign risk concerns. The two other major planks of the government’s economic policy are a commitment to renewables and Net Zero, and heavy spending, including on public sector employment. These signature policies are compounding our economic woes.
These outcomes were seemingly predicted by everyone other than the government. Or were they predicted, in which case we have a bigger problem in that the government deliberately sought to inflict economic damage on the country? The reality probably lies somewhere in the middle. The government likely knew there would be some immediate short term politically difficult impacts but calculated that by the next election things will have sufficiently improved and their ideological aim of wealth redistribution will have been achieved. If so, this is looking like a serious miscalculation. The economic data is not improving and a comparison between the Australian situation and comparable nations is making our government looking decidedly less competent than its peers.
The government is now on the horns of a dilemma. It can change course and hope this turns things around. This would be an admission of failure. Alternatively, it can hold the course it set and hope for a miracle. The polls suggest that no amount of spin or rhetoric will convince Australians we are on the right track. The steady as we go approach seems to be chosen course. The ending of the war in Iran or Ukraine and the AI revolution is highly unlikely to come to the rescue. If anything, we are ill-equipped to navigate the short- term economic impacts of AI.
To turn the current trajectory around, the government will need to consider the likely economic reality that only private investment, innovation, and entrepreneurship can be trusted to restore productivity and drive the economy. The government needs to unleash rather than shackle these forces.
The Treasurer wishes to redefine capitalism and the current government strongly believes in big government. These hard ideological settings and self-perceptions need some serious reflection in light of current circumstances and clear policy failures.
The post The plane has crashed into the mountain appeared first on The Spectator Australia.


