It has been said that demography is destiny. Given this, Australia’s destiny will be vastly different to today. The enormous change in Australia (with a birth rate per woman below replacement at 1.48) is driven by declining birth rates, something common in all Western and many Asian countries. Even India’s birth rate is falling to below replacement rate.
What does that mean for Australia, and does it even matter? Is this issue too sensitive to discuss, perhaps it is even racist?
The rate of decline in birth rates is truly shocking. Louise Perry (author of The Case Against the Sexual Revolution) compares the declining birthrate of the UK (1.55) to the impact of the medieval Black Death in Europe, where 30-60 per cent of the population perished.
Perry points out that a sustained fertility rate below 1.0 mathematically creates a 94 per cent contraction over a few generations.
She says, ‘That means for every hundred … alive today there will be six great-grandchildren, so that’s an incredibly aggressive selection pressure over the course of maybe a century … much greater than the Black Death. That’s much greater than any war.’
It gets worse.
Historical plague survivors retained the biological and social inclination to rebuild. Modern low fertility is a voluntary demographic decline.
Of course, the UK is not at a fertility rate below 1.0, but South Korea is (0.72, with a slight rebound in the last two years up to 0.8), and the UK is on a trajectory similar to South Korea, as is Australia.
There are different theories about the cause of fertility decline. Some say it’s economics, some say it’s technology, and others say it’s culture. Most likely it’s all three, but culture tends to drive most things.
‘Technology’ includes contraception, and maybe in the future robotic companions. ‘Economic’ includes housing costs, childcare costs, and cost-of-living. ‘Culture’ includes more women in the workforce, gender wars, failure to find partners or finding them late in life, and high expectations of what resources are required to raise children. Safe and easy access abortion also has a role. Whatever the reason, there is a decline in birth rates throughout the world, other than a few exceptions such as Israel and some African countries.
Both the United Kingdom and Australia run welfare states, so what does population decline mean for a welfare state?
Well, it can’t be good.
Governments with welfare states have found it exceedingly difficult to wind back welfare entitlements. Heavily indebted welfare countries continue to announce new benefits, with both sides of politics addicted to buying votes.
No government has so far been able to move the dial much on birth rates, despite a wide range of pro-natal policies being tried. Therefore, as the birth rate continues to decline, migration will be the only solution for a welfare state.
The two highest immigrant countries to Australia are India, then China, then other SE Asian countries. It is likely that these countries will continue to be the source of migrants. Although these immigrant countries are experiencing similar demographic decline themselves, migrants from poorer counties typically wish to immigrate to richer countries.
Australia certainly has benefited enormously from migration in the past. Typically, the second generation of migrants marry into the resident culture and become ‘Aussies’. But there is a difference between being the numerically dominant resident culture to becoming a minority resident culture.
When the existing culture’s birth rate declines below replacement, against a background of large-scale migration, what then happens to national identity, and the Australian culture? Does it even matter? And what is the Australian culture anyway?
It is an interesting exercise to ask AI what the Australian culture is, and then consider how robust these cultural values are…
AI says the core cultural Australian values are:
Mateship, the no-worries attitude, informality, unique humour, outdoor and beach lifestyle, obsession with sport, thriving café and coffee culture, deep Indigenous roots, multicultural mosaic, and linguistic slang.
Most of these values, such as mateship, no-worries attitude, unique humour, outdoor and beach lifestyle, obsession with sport, coffee culture, and multicultural mosaic, are not really unique to Australia.
Many countries have their own humour, coffee culture is everywhere, sport obsession is common in other countries, and multiculturalism is common in all Anglo countries. Australian slang is endearing, but not much more than that. Mateship is too blokey for progressives, and toxic masculinity adjacent.
What values are left as uncontested are the Australian beach culture and informality. Which is not much for the basis of a unique culture. Australian culture is much more diluted than it used to be due to modernity and urbanisation. Against this background, the chance of what is left of the Australian culture surviving against the pressures of a falling birth rate and large-scale migration, is slim.
These issues are too hot politically to discuss because it can be coded as a racist replacement argument. This will make open discussion about these issues seem a bit low status, and not suitable for dinner party conversation, which is probably why it is not being discussed now. There are many cultural institutions in Australia that would be quite pleased to see the demise of what is left of the Australian culture, but at the same time there are plenty of people who dearly like to hang onto what is left of the culture.
The tensions from mass migration are already being felt with the rise of One Nation. However, given the failure of any country to significantly reverse falling birth rates, the needs of a welfare state, and the continuation of cultural issues driving the demographics, there is an overwhelming sense of inevitability of large-scale change in Australia due to falling birthrates. Demography is indeed your destiny.
The post Demography is destiny appeared first on The Spectator Australia.


