‘We can’t risk it,’ said Mel, nine-year-old Taylor’s social worker. Taylor had been invited to a sleepover party, and although as her foster carer I had what social services call ‘delegated authority’ – the rubber-stamping of straightforward parenting decisions like playdates and haircuts – overnight stays were off-limits without permission. ‘I need to do a DBS check.’
When it suits, safeguarding turns out to be remarkably asymmetric
Unfortunately for Taylor, someone in her friend’s household failed their enhanced check. I wasn’t told who or why. Another mother kindly offered to host instead, but when I explained that she and every other adult under her roof would need to be vetted, she paled. ‘Ooh, I’m not sure we’d…’
‘I’ll have them at mine,’ I stepped in, to spare her the discomfort of explaining.
Welcome to the world of social care, where even the remotest of risks must be anticipated, recorded, and wherever possible, stamped out. A friend of mine and her husband, empty nesters who missed the hubbub of family life, recently applied to foster. Partway through the gruelling assessment, a DBS check flagged up some minor indiscretion from 30 years earlier.
Despite being successful parents of four well adjusted, decent citizens, all in responsible jobs, a youthful mistake three decades in the past halted their application in its tracks.
The same hyper-caution stretches beyond registration, and into every aspect of fostering family life. When our foster carer support group suggested a hillside walk for the children, one of the social workers insisted that we all needed high-vis jackets.
‘It’s only a short walk up the hill to the tea shop,’ we assured her, resisting the urge to add, not an expedition up Snowdonia.
‘Oh, but it may get dark early,’ she warned.
It was mid-summer. In the end the bureaucracy proved too exhausting and we went to the local park instead.
So risk averse is the state, that even regular visitors to the fostering household must be screened. When my male cousin came down from Scotland to stay for a few weeks, he couldn’t sleep under our roof until his enhanced DBS check came back clear. It wasn’t enough for me to vouch for him. In social care, safeguarding is absolute and non-negotiable.
I’m not complaining. If stringent checks help to secure the safety of society’s most vulnerable, I’m more than happy to comply.
What gets my goat is that, when it suits, safeguarding turns out to be remarkably asymmetric.
When it’s about an individual child in the foster home, even what some might view as healthy risk, must be viewed with suspicion. But when it comes to the safety of an entire community, the state’s appetite for risk seems to expand considerably.
At MoD Bicester, on the doorstep of the idyllic Oxfordshire village of Piddington, the same state apparatus that insisted on a formal risk assessment of our teacup puppy, is pressing ahead with plans to house up to 1256 predominantly male asylum seekers, despite fierce local opposition and serious concerns about safety and the impact on the community.
The government insists that the vast majority of these men pose no threat, and they may well be right, but since when did well meaning faith in human nature pass for an adequate safeguarding strategy? If I arranged a gathering and invited a hundred men I’d never met to come along, assuring my social worker I was confident that most of them were probably perfectly nice, I’d be laughed out of the room, and probably out of a job as well.
It’s an institutional double standard that can be seen throughout the care system. Foster carers are expected to demonstrate an understanding of risk and a judgement sound enough to anticipate it, rather than waiting for something terrible to happen before asking whether enough mitigation was put in place. Our private lives are scrutinised for the same reason, because it’s recognised that the environment around the child matters.
And yet the government routinely extends the benefit of the doubt when placing men who claim to be children in foster homes alongside vulnerable teenagers, or next to girls at school, flexing the safeguarding rules at the expense of the children already there. In the village of Piddington, the risk is being scaled up to the entire community, forcing local children and their families to absorb whatever fallout that may bring.
Ministers regularly claim to be on a mission to halve violence against women and girls and to make public spaces safer, but they seem to be entirely relaxed about placing hundreds of men, many coming from places where women and girls do not necessarily enjoy equal standing, on the edge of a village where they will be vastly outnumbered.
It seems that all the usual rules go out the window when it politically suits. An easy win would be to reverse the decision to outnumber the women of Piddington eight to one, but instead of committing to protect them, the state is apparently consulting on staggering the age of consent. We all want to protect teenagers, but threats needs triage, and more urgent is protecting women and girls who do not consent to an influx of young men on their streets.
As foster carers we’re constantly lectured on the importance of ‘listening to the voice of the child’, and yet when the children of Piddington sent handwritten letters to the Prime Minister earlier this year, their fears were dismissed out of hand. Where is the assessment of the impact on the children in this community? Surely the parents of Piddington have a right to expect that the government applies the same safeguarding rigour as it applies to a nine-year-old’s sleepover.
In every other sphere of British life, safeguarding doesn’t mean hoping that most people mean well; it requires us to verify that they are who they claim to be before we let them through the door. Except, it seems, if you live in Piddington.
Names have been changed
The post Why doesn’t the state care about safeguarding in Piddington? appeared first on The Spectator Australia.


