Baby Boomers have been called many things, usually by people waiting for them to sell their houses.
Recently, I’ve referred to them as the ‘narrative generation’.
That isn’t an insult. It doesn’t mean they were stupid or unusually gullible. They grew up in a world where checking an official claim was difficult enough to qualify as a hobby. If the government made an announcement, the evening news reported it and the morning papers confirmed it, most people reasonably assumed it was true. Disproving it required a library card, a cooperative expert, and several afternoons nobody with a mortgage and three children had to spare.
The postwar information system had competing mastheads, but information still passed through the same narrow gateways: government departments, established experts, wire services, and major newsrooms. If they agreed, the narrative became reality. No smoky room was required. Scarcity, authority, and the cost of distribution did the work. Boomers didn’t surrender their judgment; the world gave them too little material with which to exercise it.
Truth arrived at six o’clock wearing a tie.
Then the internet blew the gates off their hinges. Millennials and older Gen Z became the search generation. An official statement was no longer the end of an inquiry but the beginning. Within minutes, somebody could find the original document, an inconvenient statistic, or an expert who hadn’t been invited onto the ABC. Governments could still make their case, but they had lost their monopoly on being believed.
The internet also delivered industrial quantities of rubbish. For every buried report it uncovered, somebody uploaded a video explaining that the moon was a government lampshade. Plenty used Google only to confirm what they already believed. But it taught us one profoundly democratic habit: there was always another version of the story.
That habit has been politically disruptive. Institutions accustomed to being trusted were suddenly asked to show their working. Governments responded by warning about misinformation and disinformation. Sometimes rightly – the internet is a sewer with Wi-Fi. But the people who spent decades defining truth were never going to enjoy being asked for receipts.
The Albanese government’s Misinformation and Disinformation Bill died in the Senate in 2024. Its new Digital Duty of Care Bill isn’t the same proposal, and its stated targets include vile material and protecting children. But the direction of travel matters. The regulatory perimeter is expanding around the services through which Australians encounter information, including AI chatbots. The moment government says platforms have a duty to protect users from harm, who defines harm, and how long before a dangerous act and a dangerous opinion begin sharing a postcode?
This matters because AI changes the process of finding things out. Google presented a page of links and forced the user to make a judgment. AI presents an answer. It feels like progress because the argument has disappeared, but the argument hasn’t been resolved. It has merely been hidden inside the machine.
Search made bias visible. You could see the masthead, the author and the address of the website attempting to sell you miracle vitamins. AI makes bias atmospheric. It selects the sources, weighs their authority, resolves their contradictions, and delivers the result in the calm prose of an exceptionally patient schoolteacher. Search made us choose between sources. AI chooses between sources before we arrive.
AI could become the greatest fact-checking instrument ever invented. It can compare documents and expose contradictions in seconds. But it will only help if the user remains sceptical. Most won’t seek dissenting evidence, inspect the citations and question the assumptions embedded in the answer. When the machine sounds neutral and vastly better informed, convenience will do what censorship often can’t: make verification feel unnecessary.
The old media system was concentrated, but at least its mastheads quarrelled in public. The next may be mediated by a handful of companies whose models rely on overlapping sources, safety rules, legal pressures, and definitions of authoritative information. They don’t need to meet in a bunker and agree on the daily narrative. Conformity can emerge perfectly well from common incentives and a shared fear of regulators.
Nor is government pressure hypothetical. Mark Zuckerberg later acknowledged that the Biden Administration repeatedly pressed Meta to restrict certain Covid content, including humour and satire. Whatever one thinks of the disputed claims, the lesson was unmistakable: governments will try to influence private information gateways when they dislike what is passing through them.
Children growing up now won’t regard AI as a novelty. It will be their tutor, author, researcher, counsellor, and perhaps their friend. They’ll ask a question, receive a fluent paragraph and move on. The official story won’t arrive from a stern newsreader behind a desk. It will arrive in a voice they selected, adjusted to their reading level and informed by everything the machine remembers about them.
That makes the new narrative system potentially more powerful than the old one. Boomers knew they were watching the news. Their grandchildren may think they’re merely having a conversation.
This doesn’t mean AI is evil or that the search age was golden. Google could bury the truth beneath sponsored sludge, and several browser tabs never made anyone an intellectual giant. Our information architecture trained one generation to receive, the next to search, and the next may be trained to receive once again.
The internet didn’t end the narrative age. It just gave us an intermission.
The post The search generation was only an intermission appeared first on The Spectator Australia.


