There was a great deal of anticipation surrounding the Victorian Leaders’ Debate last night.
Hosted on the freshly rebranded News24 (formerly Sky News Australia) it was notable for being the only debate between leaders of the four parties vying for government.
Ben Carroll, Jess Wilson, Warren Pickering, and Ellen Sandell maintained a remarkably restrained appearance, which makes determining the winner more difficult.
Gone are the days when debates were mandatory and common. Welcome to the age where politicians have to be coaxed into single combat by a major news network with the upstart minor party, One Nation, nipping at their heels in the hope of doing preemptive damage when Labor and Liberal tried to run away. As for the Greens, they were ‘there’ because Labor is rarely without its socialist sidekick.
Major parties dislike in-person, televised debates for the same reason they’ve been cracking down on social media: safety. Not for children, but for themselves and the reputation of their parties.
Nothing falls apart faster in a debate than a weak party and charlatan leader.
Yes, it leaves newcomers open to displaying inexperience in front of the media, though I would argue the damage is far more brutal to the practised individuals whose slick veneer cracks in front of voters.
How did the debate go?
I’m not sure what to make of it, to be honest.
This was not as theatrical, in-depth, or instructive as an American presidential debate, nor are its players willing to sink their teeth in beyond a few minor skirmishes. The host, Kieran Gilbert, pushed a little (very briefly and all-too softly), never receiving a direct answer. The closest he got to holding a speaker to account was Greens Leader Ellen Sandell on her refusal to acknowledge rampant antisemitism and acts of violence in pro-Palestine marches during a discussion about introducing permits for protests.
Ms Sandell was the weak link in the debate. She was more polished than Warren Pickering, but like Carroll and Wilson, she was offering pre-rehearsed camouflage for bad policy. Sandell was enticed into accidentally breaking that facade several times, most notably by Pickering who pointed out that ‘free’ promises from the Greens are actually taxpayer-funded costs. Pickering, in contrast, had no facade to break. His strength is the same as party leader Pauline Hanson – what you see is what you get. Ask him a question and you’ll get an answer, even if it is slightly stuttered under the bright studio lights. Some commentators may see this as a detraction for Pickering, and it might be for disengaged swing voters in Victoria who mistake political practice for governance competence. However, comments online after the debate suggest that his honesty and grounded presentation worked in his favour for those who mistrust the promises of career politicians. In which case, who knows. This election is as unusual as its candidates.
We can say with confidence that Sandell lost the support of Victorians (although not the 25 per cent of audience voters who picked her as the winner) when she started saying that ‘free’ stuff would be paid for by ‘corporations … from their massive profits’.
The Greens Leader also went on a whacko rant about tech, championing her party as some sort of luddite revolution against the modern world, which is a bizarre choice given the average age of Greens voters.
‘To stop Big AI Tech Bro Billionaires coming from Silicon Valley and using Victoria as a dumping ground for vampire data centres that take our energy, our water, and our housing land.’
Hostility toward Silicon Valley evidently extends beyond their desire to censor social media. Strange how we never see any headlines from MSM about the anti-tech Greens. It was one of the few positions that shone through coherently.
Sandell proved herself to be an industrial-level political figure who rarely gave an answer that remotely matched the Greens social media account, policy list, or the majority opinion of their voters. In my view, she is carrying on the tradition of presenting a ‘campaign Green’ and ‘government Green’ split personality disorder common amongst her kin.
There is plenty of window dressing around the Victorian election, and yet it is likely to repeat the same duopoly of power: Labor vs Liberal.
Premier Ben Carroll and Opposition Leader Jess Wilson are professional, life-long politicians and thoroughly competent when trading blows. They joked and prodded each other, comfortable with the game of politics. It is a skit the voters have seen a thousand times before. Their soundbites, clipped out of the monotony, are polished and convincing. Which is the point. Labor and Liberal are selling the same message: ‘safe pair of hands’. It works a little better for Wilson given Carroll is preaching from the wreck of reality.
This performance had its low points. Particularly, when Wilson was trying to goad Carroll into saying Daniel Andrews’ name, invoking him like a malicious spirit to haunt the election. His refusal to do so was embarrassing and comical (in a depressing way) when Wilson immediately chirped ‘Jeff Kennett’ on demand. This stuff is childish. Imagine a business where a former employee’s name cannot be spoken when trying to sort out the mess they left behind. We give politicians a pass for this because it evokes a momentary smile that masks its absurdity.
Carroll did his best to avoid accountability for the disgraceful state of Victoria after more than a decade of Labor control. Wilson left shallow wounds on Carroll while talking in circles around left-wing topics and offering clarity on only the least contentious issues, such as tough bail laws.
Nowhere was the quality of debate more on the nose than during the ‘should we have a dedicated Minister for Autism’ conversation. Carroll committed immediately, despite an unknown cost and no evidence that this massive extension of bureaucracy would have even the slightest impact on the problem. Wilson talked high and low about reform in an effort to spare the feelings of the questioner and to be so incomprehensible in reply as to foil ABC criticism. Sandell agreed to anything ‘free’ without the slightest thought crossing her mind. It was only Pickering who echoed the wider audience in total astonishment. He defied the status quo and called on existing departments to do their jobs without wasting additional public money. Bravo. It was one of his strongest moments and, importantly, unrehearsed. It demonstrated that his instinct is to serve the public, not activist talking points and election polls. That is more valuable than most people realise.
Who won the debate? News24 says it was the Liberal leader, Jess Wilson, by miles, with Ben Carroll scoring below the undecided vote on a humiliating 7 per cent.
As for the election, that is harder to say. The general consensus this morning is that little has changed. Not only because so few saw the debate. There was nothing about this exchange that sufficiently challenged the leaders, and that is the fault of the host network. It was soft. Victorians need something hard. With so much at stake, it is a shame this is the only time we will see these people outside their campaign machinery.
Who will be the next Premier? Probably Jess Wilson. Mind you, this is Victoria, so who knows!
Alexandra Marshall is an independent writer. If you would like to support her work, shout her a coffee over at donor-box.
The post Who won the Victorian Leaders’ Debate? appeared first on The Spectator Australia.


