The Hague
The US Ambassador to the UN, Mike Waltz, issued a warning to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on X last month: the US ‘will not allow globalist, faux-judges to weaponise the law against our troops, undermine our sovereignty, or put American lives at risk’.
No state has been found guilty of committing genocide by an international court before. Such a ruling would be historic
Waltz, a close Trump ally, was commenting as the conclusion of the dispute between The Gambia and Myanmar approached. Today, the ICJ will rule whether genocide was committed by Myanmar against the Rohingya people, and a ruling against Myanmar could have far reaching implications for the Court itself. Just weeks after the US sanctioned the International Criminal Court (ICC), international experts fear that the US could do the same to the ICJ.
The case is already novel. Though all member states of the UN are party to the ICJ, the ICJ cannot compel states to appear before it. Jurisdiction has to be agreed and only 38 per cent of UN member states recognise this automatically (through filed declarations) – in fact, the UK is the only permanent member of the Security Council to do so. For The Gambia to bring the case against Myanmar – which it did so as a Muslim-majority country, representing the 57 countries of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation – it relied on the Genocide Convention. The 1949 treaty recognises the ICJ as the dispute mechanism for issues over application of the treaty – something which Myanmar has signed and ratified.
This is the same mechanism by which South Africa filed a case against Israel, at the end of 2023, over possible genocide in Gaza – and this gets to the crux of why the American administration is concerned about the ICJ judgment. The ICJ, which was originally concerned with more general topics of international law, like maritime disputes and diplomatic immunity, has seen more and more human rights cases brought before it and, right now, has more cases being considered than at any other time in its 80-year history. Today’s judgment could set a precedent for future genocide cases, as opponents of the case argue that such a judgment would broaden the definition of genocide.
When considering both cases, legal experts I spoke to in The Hague argue that the case against Israel is clearer than that against Myanmar, as per the convention, and thus more likely to be found true. This is partly due to the larger amount of evidence collected for the Gaza case, as well as certain statements made by Israeli politicians. Access and consensus has been more limited with Myanmar.
This matters as it means that not only does a judgment against Myanmar impact definition, but it sends a signal about the outcome of the case against Israel. A recent Wall Street Journal (WSJ) op ed made this link, saying the case ‘has nothing to do with Myanmar’s mistreatment of the Rohingya…the change would be needed only to help South Africa’s case against Israel’. It argued this was part of a broader move by, what it termed, the ‘global left’ to redefine genocide. Supporters of the ICJ decouple the cases, defending the integrity of the Court, and pointing out that The Gambia brought the case in 2019, years before Israel’s incursion into the Gaza Strip.
The WSJ op ed went further, arguing that a broader definition could be used ‘to hold over the US as a threat’, claiming that future military endeavours by the US – ‘and allied’ – soldiers would be impacted negatively by such a judgment. These concerns are shared by the prominent British lawyer Joshua Rozenberg who argued that the UK, and others, ‘may now find themselves vulnerable to lawfare’.
If the case is found against Myanmar, the fear is that the ICJ may be targeted by the US, just as the ICC has been. But what does this mean in practice? While international legal experts fear a US response, they are in broad agreement that sanctions would likely be brought against individuals rather than the Court itself.
This is what happened initially with sanctions against the ICC, which were first brought – briefly – at the end of the first Trump administration (and revoked by the Biden administration). A fresh round of individual sanctions were brought during the second Trump administration last year, with individuals facing travel bans and asset freezes.
This escalated last month when US citizens were forbidden from doing business with the entire Court. Now, individuals associated with the ICC have begun facing issues with everyday activities like accessing banking and booking travel tickets. A body of work is ongoing exploring how to protect individuals within the EU associated with the Court and how to prevent overcompliance – where companies with few links to the US follow the sanctions purely as risk mitigation.
This itself has implications for the EU as it seeks to reduce its technological reliance on the US. A legal expert said to me that while the ICC was originally ‘90 per cent reliant’ on the US technologically, this has reduced to around ‘40 per cent’. This diminishing of American influence has not gone unnoticed. Last week, when Microsoft Outlook crashed, the ICC wasn’t affected – as it had adopted a German alternative.
With two more years of Trump, the ICJ faces more challenging times ahead
All this has influenced those thinking of the possible consequences of the ICJ judgement. Even if sanctions are not brought, or are brought and one day lifted, many European-based international organisations are seeking to ‘de-Americanise’ their institutions. This issue of ‘digital sovereignty’ is one argument being used by those who wish to warn the US that such threats are bad for business.
No state has been found guilty of committing genocide by an international court before. Such a ruling would be historic, and that is before even taking into consideration all the potential implications. But, equally, if the Court were to rule against The Gambia – that there has been no defined genocide – that does not disprove other war crimes or violations of international law by Myanmar. And that doesn’t mean that America will reduce its pressure on the Court. With two more years of Trump, the ICJ faces more challenging times ahead.<//>
The post The ICJ’s genocide verdict will lead to international lawfare appeared first on The Spectator Australia.


